Successful business planning and development requires a good understanding of market potential, and of your capabilities against those of your competitors.
Yet, 92% of respondents in a US
survey felt that they needed a more systematic approach to competitor intelligence, while 75% of respondents in a UK survey were dissatisfied with their current methods of organising marketing
information. What these organisations lack is an effective Market Intelligence System (MkIS).
What is a Market Intelligence System?
A Market Intelligence System (MkIS) is one that systematically gathers and processes critical business information, transforming it into actionable management intelligence for
Note the following points:
- Market intelligence is not just about market information, but the whole gamut of external environment information needed to support key strategic decisions - about products, prices, investment
priorities, entering joint ventures etc.
- The system is not purely a computer-based system. It is a total system that incorporates human processes for interpreting and processing information into intelligence.
- The processes must be systematic, since only regular monitoring of key external parameters and integration of disparate snippets of information will give a viable long-term intelligence
Benefits of an MkIS
- Market and customer orientation - implementing an MkIS will encourage people throughout the organisation to focus externally.
- Identification of new opportunities One company in a component industry identified a new trend before the 'expert' industry analysts.
- Early warning of competitor moves - through good intelligence, One chemical company thwarted the siting of a competitor's manufacturing plant in one of their most profitable sales
- Minimizing investment risk - ongoing intelligence and analysis is more likely to temper unbridled enthusiasm to follow the bandwagon into those "mustn't miss the window of opportunity"
- Better customer interaction - An insurance company downloads into their salespeople's portables up to date profiles, order history and relevant 'news bites', for the clients they are about to
- Better market selection & positioning - good understanding of customer needs and competitor positioning will help a company better carve out its own unique niche
- Quicker, more efficient and cost-effective information - establishment of a system will make information more quickly and easily accessible. One company avoided the need for an expensive piece of
market research by tapping into its existing MkIS.
Key Elements of an MkIS
A continuous flow of information is the lifeblood of a good market intelligence system - information about new technologies, markets, customers, the economic and regulatory environment etc. Both
formal (routine reporting, factual) and informal information (gossip, opinions) must be tapped.
Information Management Processes
With many professionals having external information delivered to their desktops, from online services such as Reuters or MAID, and increasingly from the Internet is easy to believe that users have
all the information they need on tap. However, this is raw information and will need transforming into intelligence. Before that, however, this information must be classified, stored and made
accessible - applying good practice principles of Information Resources Management (IRM).
Intelligence Development Processes
A good intelligence system is more than information. It is a recurring cycle of linking the needs of decision makers to the processes of turning the information into actionable intelligence.
This requires human interpretation, communicating and sharing of information and perspectives between internal and external experts.
A comprehensive MkIS will combine many of the features of decision support systems, EIS, online databases and library systems. It is therefore likely to include many of the following:
- For gathering information: CD-ROMs, online data-base access, data feeds, email, Internet access, filters, intelligent agents etc.
- For storage and retrieval:Database/document management facilities, text retrieval, search engines, intelligent agents
- For processing and analysis: modelling and visualisation software, groupware, group decision support systems (GDSS)
An Organizational Focus
Although many professionals do much of their own information gathering and analysis, there still needs to be a clear focal point of MkIS responsibility. This may be a named individual or a small
group who have the distinctive skills needed (such as those promulgated by SCIP - the Society for Competitor Intelligence Professionals). Its role is to ensure a
cohesive approach and effective interdepartmental co-ordination.
Developing an MkIS
MkIS in most organisations evolves through several phases:
- Ad-Hoc. Individuals collect their own information. This phase culminates when management recognises the need to focus resources.
- Establishment of a specialist unit.
- Introduction of computer based solutions.
- Evolution into a full global electronic network.
- Recognition of information as a corporate asset with appropriate information resource management (IRM) policies and procedures.
- When appropriate, treating the resultant intelligence as a tradable commodity, to be shared with partners or sold externally.
Most organisations today are at stages 2-3.
- Strategic Analysis & Scenario Planning
- Environment Forecasting
- Acquisition targets
- Location of new plants
- Supplier evaluation
- Marketing Planning
- Industry analysis
- Competitor analysis
- New product introductions
- Product portfolio
- Sales & Marketing
- Sales cycle management (targetting etc)
- Database marketing
- Sales forecasting
- Promotion campaign assessment
10 Steps to Success
- 1. Define the Customers.
- Always a good place to start! For MkIS there are usually three distinct groups of customers who will need different solutions:
- Field Personnel e.g. sales and service - their needs are immediate and specific: "I want the price of product X for competitor Y ... and I want it yesterday!"
- Marketers and planners - more strategic but focused; market and product trends to develop marketing plans and adjust the mix - pricing, packaging promotion etc.
- Board level management - strategic and broad: general industry and market developments that affect investment and other strategic decisions.
- 2. Understand Needs
- A common starting point is an information audit a detailed analysis of information entities - their origins, uses, and formats. However, we would advocate a less onerous and more focused
approach - the study of your customers' work and decisions, using structured interviews (taped if possible), focus groups etc.
- 3. Map Needs against Decisions & Sources
- This will list information originators and users, sources required and decision supported. It will also identify high pay-off opportunities, for example where certain information has multiple
- 4. Implement a Sourcing Strategy
- The source/needs map from step 3 will point to clusters of information needs that can give economies in purchasing. For example, purchasing a networked CD-ROM may be more cost-effective than
doing multiple ad-hoc online searches.
- 5. Define Information Policies & Standards
- Steps 1-4 will reveal, often to many people for the first time, the sheer wealth of information that is available. This step therefore involves classification standards, ownership, life-cycle
management standards and agreed 'protocols and procedures' between owners and users.
- 6. Select a Pilot Project.
- This is to create a 'quick win' to demonstrate the power of an MkIS. Select a key decision process that involves people across several departments. Pricing can be a good one. It is something that
needs to be reviewed regularly and has direct bottom line impact - a 1% price change flows straight to the bottom line and can equate to more than a 10% change in sales. The careful selection of a
pilot cannot be overestimated. Pick the wrong one, and it be difficult to regain credibility.
- 7. Select & Adapt Appropriate Technology
- With the selected pilot project acting as a focal point, now is the time to start detailed consideration of the computer solution. The choices are bewildering, and are proliferating daily.
Therefore, selecting the right solution may need the involvement (or even the approval) of your MIS department - but make sure they are well-tuned into end-user computing styles (as opposed to the
"we'll give users access to the Internet over my dead body" brigade - exact words recently relayed to me by an MIS manager).
- 8. Nurture the Intelligence Processes
- This requires encouraging interaction across departmental boundaries and sub-cultures. Therefore, the creation of events and forums to encourage this interchange is often a useful starting point.
Advanced MkIS users extend their systems access to business partners and external experts as part of this process.
- 9. Focus Dissemination
- Intelligence on the shelf - or buried in a computer - is of little use to anyone. It needs to reach those in decision making situations. This can be in the form of regular dissemination, an
alerting service or responding to an ad-hoc requests to the intelligence base. Many MkIS departments issue weekly or monthly bulletins of key developments. These should be short and focused. They
give company relevant and specific information that no external newsletter, with its generic coverage, can provide.
- 10. Market the Capability
- Good MkIS managers create two way interaction with their clients. Use all the techniques of marketing to reach your internal audience and consider carefully the incentives you can offer to
encourage the regular inflow of useful information. After all the best intelligence is already probably lying somewhere within your own organisation. It comes from contacts made between employees and
the outside world - marketing people at exhibitions, business managers at professional meetings, and perhaps, most important of all - salespeople on customer visits etc.
This Insight has been summarized and updated from the author's contribution to 'How to Do it - the expert's view' in The Impact of Computerised Sales and Marketing Systems
in the UK HCG Publications (Hewson Associates).
© Copyright. David J. Skyrme. 1995, 1999. This material may be copied or distributed subject to the terms of our copyright conditions (no commercial gain; complete page copying etc.)
Further Reading and Links
Monitoring the Competition, Leonard M. Fuld, John Wiley and Sons (1988) - a golden oldie, with step-by-step guidance. More Details.
The Intelligent Corporation, Ruth Stanat, AMACOM (1990) - offers a strategic perspective and practical advice. More Details.
'The Planning and Marketing of the Market Intelligence Function', David Skyrme, Market Intelligence and Planning", Vol. 7, No. 1/2, pp.5-10 (1989)
'Developing Successful Marketing Intelligence: A Case Study', David Skyrme, Management Decision, Vol 28, No. 1, pp.54-61 (1990).
'Global Intelligence Networking: Technological Opportunities and Human Challenges', David Skyrme, AGSI Journal (Nov 1995). Synopsis and Full Article.
Related Insights on these pages include No. 8 Information Resources Management, No. 10 Knowledge Networking, No. 11
The Knowledge Asset, No. 12 Innovation through Knowledge Networking, or see full list.
Back to: Top - What Is It? - Benefits - Elements - Guidelines
- Resources - Feedback
Management Insights are publications of David Skyrme Associates, who offers strategic consulting, presentations and workshops on many of these topics.
Additional coverage of these topics can be found in our free monthly briefing I3 UPDATE/ENTOVATION International News,
various articles, publications and presentations.